IF a Tree Falls and Everybody is on the Internet…

by J.S. Gilbert
internetMarketingsocial media

There’s an old saying about a tree falling in the forest, which asks the question “If there’s no one to there to hear it fall, does it make a sound?”

It’s a fair enough question, with several potentially valid interpretations.

It got me to wondering, “If I write a blog post and nobody views it, what’s the point?”

I think that what we do online could be broken down into 2 activities; the stuff we do because we just feel like doing it and the stuff we do with some sort of purpose. I suppose Facebook realized this when it decided to have distinctions between its regular pages and business pages.

I have a business page. I’m not sure why I have one, except I somehow think that down the line, I will be glad I have one. Somehow it will help me make money. I don’t actually know how and I suspect that almost all of the people out there who claim they know how to make money with Facebook business pages are simply making money by selling other people on the fact they too can make money with a Facebook business page.

Similarly, I’m not sure that the effort I put into answering questions on LinkedIn’s and other sites or doing podcasts, my own or celebrity blogs, etc. will actually ever turn into a single red cent.

Despite the fact that everywhere you turn, there’s a new discussion about monetization, it would seem that a large part of this monetization comes from one’s ability to peddle a bit of snake oil. But then again, what is the internet but a bit of smoke and mirrors? I suppose if L. Frank Baum were to write the Wizard of Oz today, we’d peel back the curtain only to find out the whole thing was a CG creation or perhaps a virtual world.

This blog post you are reading right now, doesn’t have the right keywords or trending terms to get me SEO, but even if it did, how many people are going to read it? Those that do will probably see it as just one more little piece of writing in their day. They may go “hmmmm”. Few will comment back. Even fewer will link or refer someone to it. How many will actually take the time to go and visit other pages on my site? Will they even care about who I am or what I do?

So while I wish this blog post would help monetize me, it is very much something I do because I feel like doing it.

Judging from the vast amounts of started discussions that go undiscussed, blog posts that are read by precious few, tweets that seem to go quietly into the good night, emails that are never opened and the general hustle and bustle of just trying to get heard in today’s world, it might seem that even if there is somebody there in the forest, the tree may still not make a sound.

Be Sociable, Share!

Leave a Comment

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

1 L. C. Sterling June 21, 2012 at 5:21 pm

Wonder this all the time … if everyone’s writing blogs and posts, who’s reading?

2 Juliette Gray June 21, 2012 at 10:40 pm

Very well put JS. Glad you took the time to work out what’s really happening and how most of the things we do dumb everything down to the lowest common denominator and then that becomes the norm.

3 Greg Petropoulos June 22, 2012 at 6:42 am

It’s a writer’s bane to want to be famous. Fortunately, over time, I have learned to judge myself not by the amount of Tweeples I have (very few) but rather by the amount of prairie dogs I can fit into my pants. Three.

(I contend I could get more. But once a prairie dog sees you stuff a few of his friends down your pants, he’s tough to catch.)

In all sincerity (for realz this time), if a blog entertains just one person–even if it’s just the author–that should be enough, eh? Yeah, maybe we’ll get discovered by big Hollywood Internet agents as we blog at the soda fountain … maybe it will lead to a better job … maybe someone will list us one of their cherished “thought leaders” in the field … maybe even someone will subscribe–or leave a comment! (Can I get a hallelujah?) But monetize? No matter how hard we rub that bottle, the Blog Money Genie has been kidnapped by whoever made the Kardashians famous.

Read all about it at my blog at … just kidding.

No seriously, read my blog at http://squirrelwhipserer.blogspot.com. Adopt a puppy. Save the whales. Buy American. Send me a dollar.

4 Jim Cissell June 22, 2012 at 10:05 am

Just didn’t want you to think that no one was listening — or reading.

5 J.S. Gilbert June 22, 2012 at 10:11 am

Thanks Jim.

6 J.S. Gilbert June 22, 2012 at 10:16 am

Greg,
I’m reminded of the guy who wanted to meet women, so his friend suggest putting a potato down his pants. After two weeks with no luck, he shows up at his friends house and asks “Why isn’t it working?” To which his friend simply says “In the front!, In the front.”

I will make it a point to visit Squirrel Whisperer soon. I have already adopted a puppy. Her name is Fresca and she’s on the home page of my site. I climbed a tree last week and rescued a whale. And I just paid a guy $4,000 and I now have the deed to the United States. Should I send the dollar to you via PayPal at your gmail address?

7 J.S. Gilbert June 22, 2012 at 10:18 am

Thanks Juliette. I find myself torn between my constant desire to remain relevant and find new ways to exist in an ever changing world, and retreating to my own private world, where the Root Beer floats are made with real vanilla bean ice cream and still only cost 50 cents.

8 J.S. Gilbert June 22, 2012 at 10:21 am

Leon, I read a lot of them. In many cases I ask myself why somebody tweeted or recommended that I read the blog. Actually, much of the time I simply think after reading one, “that’s 4 minutes of my life (or 5 or 6) that I will never have back”. And if anybody wants something really good to read, try “Confessions of A Grumpy Advertising Man”, by L.C. Sterling. http://www.amazon.com/Confessions-Grumpy-Advertising-Man-ebook/dp/B007996SYC
An excellent read!

9 L. C. Sterling June 22, 2012 at 10:51 am

Thanks, J.S. You’re a scholar and a gentleman.

10 Derek Chappell June 23, 2012 at 11:04 am

Bravo J.S. I have wondered this same thing many many times, usually right after I hit ‘publish’ on a blog post and send it out into the good night. I have learned, while I review so many blogs each week to share on my blog every Saturday, that I’m just a little bitty blog in the universe of vo blogs. But for some reason, I just can’t stop.

11 Ralph Hass July 12, 2012 at 12:43 am

Hi J.S.
Time for some post-July 4th fireworks:)
I linked to you on my latest post (Has The VOice…On and Off the Ice: Giving Credit Where It’s Due) and then on Wednesday Derek Chappell linked to it here: http://www.scoop.it/t/voiceover-blogs

But the art of reciprocity seems to be lost on most folks in social media these days. I enjoy blogging (almost five years) and it serves as another creative outlet for me. So load up that (b)logging truck because more trees are going to be falling because of us:)

12 J.S. Gilbert July 14, 2012 at 1:14 pm

Thanks Ralph, and I’ll make it a point to visit your blog from time to time and see what you have to say.

Previous post:

Next post: